Top 5 Butter Brands in the US in 2024

Butter is an essential ingredient in kitchens across America, and several brands have become household names due to their quality and consistency. Here, we take a closer look at the top 5 butter brands in the US in 2024, exploring their history, locations, partnerships with grocery chains, and how you can enjoy these butters with a Butter Bell Crock.

1. Land O'Lakes

History: Founded in 1921, Land O'Lakes is a farmer-owned cooperative that has grown to become one of the most recognized butter brands in the United States. The company started with 320 dairy farmers in Minnesota and has expanded its reach nationwide.

Locations: Land O'Lakes products are produced in various locations across the US, with significant operations in the Midwest.

Chains: Land O'Lakes butter is widely available in major grocery chains such as Walmart, Kroger, Safeway, and Publix.

Unique Offerings: Known for its consistent quality, Land O'Lakes offers a variety of butter products, including unsalted, salted, and European-style butter.

2. Kerrygold

History: Kerrygold, established in 1962, is an Irish brand that has made a significant impact in the US market. It is owned by the Irish Dairy Board and is renowned for its high-quality grass-fed butter.

Locations: Although Kerrygold is produced in Ireland, it is widely distributed across the United States.

Chains: You can find Kerrygold butter in grocery chains such as Whole Foods, Trader Joe's, and Costco.

Unique Offerings: Kerrygold is celebrated for its rich, golden color and distinct taste, offering products like salted, unsalted, and garlic & herb butter.

3. Plugrá

History: Plugrá butter, produced by Dairy Farmers of America, has been a staple for chefs and home cooks alike since its introduction. The name "Plugrá" is derived from the French "plus gras," meaning "more fat," reflecting its higher butterfat content.

Locations: Plugrá is produced in the United States and distributed nationwide.

Chains: It is commonly found in upscale grocery stores like Whole Foods, Sprouts, and specialty food stores.

Unique Offerings: Plugrá offers European-style butter with 82% butterfat, making it ideal for baking and cooking.

4. Organic Valley

History: Organic Valley is a cooperative of organic farmers founded in 1988. They focus on producing high-quality organic dairy products, including their well-regarded butter.

Locations: Organic Valley products are produced across various US locations, supporting local organic farms.

Chains: You can find Organic Valley butter in chains like Whole Foods, Kroger, and other health-focused grocery stores.

Unique Offerings: Known for its organic and sustainable practices, Organic Valley offers both salted and unsalted butter, made from pasture-raised cows.

5. Challenge Butter

History: Established in 1911, Challenge Butter has a long history of producing high-quality butter. Based in California, it is known for its dedication to freshness and flavor.

Locations: Challenge Butter is produced in California and distributed throughout the United States.

Chains: This brand is widely available in grocery chains like Walmart, Albertsons, and Ralphs.

Unique Offerings: Challenge Butter offers a range of products, including European-style, spreadable, and whipped butter.

The Perfect Pairing: Butter Bell Crock

A Butter Bell Crock is the ideal way to store your favorite butter brands. It keeps butter fresh and spreadable at room temperature without refrigeration. Simply pack the butter into the bell-shaped lid, add water to the base, and enjoy soft, spreadable butter anytime. Whether you prefer the rich taste of Kerrygold or the high butterfat content of Plugrá, a Butter Bell Crock ensures your butter is always at its best.